GROOVE ARCHIVE
← Pop
Ys

Pop / Art pop · 2006

Ys

Joanna Newsom

Why listen

Five extended songs make harp patterns, changing sentences and orchestral responses follow different paths through the same musical space.

Listen and read

Tracks · previews

English editorial edition

Album story

Ys contains five tracks, but their scale changes what a track can mean. Emily opens beyond twelve minutes, while Only Skin approaches seventeen. These lengths do not promise an uninterrupted wall of sound. Harp patterns, sentences and instrumental responses can develop at different rates. Rather than decoding every image immediately, follow whether the end of a phrase brings familiar music back or opens another direction.

Joanna Newsom released this second album through Drag City in 2006. Van Dyke Parks’s orchestral arrangements matter, yet the music is more than a singer placed inside a large ensemble. Newsom described recording harp and vocals before the arrangements were written. The finished performance could therefore inform the orchestration. Keep the songwriter’s role distinct from the arranger’s, and consider the interaction between their musical decisions rather than counting decorative instruments.

An opening that teaches its scale

Emily offers recurring harp movement as a guide through an extended vocal line. Familiar accompaniment does not guarantee that the next sentence will occupy the same length or arrive at the same destination. Notice where instruments answer, connect or expand a phrase. The changing relationship between intimate address and wider imagery can remain meaningful without identifying every image with a specific biographical event.

The middle changes the focus

Sawdust & Diamonds follows Monkey & Bear. Concentrate here on the relationship between plucked notes and the voice: clear attacks and lingering resonance provide distinct reference points. When words gather quickly or a phrase stretches out, ask whether the harp moves with them. Reduced instrumental density need not mean a simpler form. This central position offers another way into the album’s long spans.

After the longest piece

Only Skin is followed by Cosmia, so the longest track does not occupy the final position. Even the shorter closing piece exceeds seven minutes. The album establishes its own relative scale. Listen beyond the expectation of one enormous climax and notice what the conclusion changes. Preserving the five track boundaries helps distinguish their different weights instead of treating the record as one undifferentiated epic.

The album through its tracks

Follow the recurring harp and extended sentences in Emily, then examine their relationship more closely in Sawdust & Diamonds.

  1. Emily

    At approximately twelve minutes and eight seconds, the opener quickly establishes a scale beyond a compact chorus cycle. Remember a returning harp figure and follow how far the sentence above it travels. Familiar music does not necessarily return the story to the same place; repetition can change the significance of material already heard. When other instruments enter, consider whether they answer a phrase or connect one thought to another. You need not solve every image to find useful landmarks in attacks, arrivals and returns. This selection is the original studio recording, not a later orchestral concert performance. After reaching the end, revisit the opening and compare its apparent weight.

    Reference · Joanna Newsom / Drag City Bandcamp: complete original programme and lengths
  2. Sawdust & Diamonds

    The third track lasts approximately nine minutes and fifty-five seconds. Follow the harp separately from the vocal line, noticing how plucked attacks establish movement while consonants and sustained vowels occupy different lengths. The instrument supplies more than a wash of gentle resonance: the beginning of each note can matter as much as its decay. A passage that initially sounds less crowded may still contain changing relationships between its parts. Rather than assigning a single solution to each image, ask whether accompaniment and sentence move together. Remember its position between Monkey & Bear and Only Skin. This is the 2006 album recording, not a performance from the separate EP or a concert.

    Reference · The Wire: unedited Joanna Newsom interview about composition and recording

Listen next

Continue to Kate Bush’s Aerial and compare another way of preserving individual songs within an extended musical design.

Aerial ↗
References & editorial note

Written for English readers. Album facts are referenced below; listening suggestions are editorial interpretations. AI-assisted editorial review; not independently human-reviewed.